This is a long-overdue post, but it’s taken me this long to sort out my thoughts on the subject and not rant and rave incoherently.
Back in May I started to see links to this article on several blogs. Almost everyone who linked to it seemed to agree with the author Russell Moore, who states that all romance novels – even the Christian ones, even the YA ones, even the ones with no sex scenes – can “hurt your heart” if you’re a woman. He worries that reading romance novels is the equivalent of porn for women. It might make us discontented with real life relationships, if we’re expecting an Alpha Male Hero and instead get, as he puts it, “what by comparison must seem to be underachieving lumps lying next to them on the couch”.
There were a few other articles at the same time, which I can’t find now to link to, saying much the same thing: Romance novels give women unrealistic expectations about love and men and romance and life. They encourage us to believe in happily ever after. They fill our heads with happy fluffy nonsense and turn us into mushy nitwits.
And always that refrain of “porn for women”.
Let me get my issues with that out of the way first: If you’re talking about the books where a thin veneer of plot is stretched between graphic, descriptive sex scenes, I agree with you. That is porn for women, because its only purpose is to arouse the reader, in the same way that “porn for men”, or visual porn, is designed only to arouse the viewer.
But to take that so far that you’d say Beverly Lewis’s books about Amish people falling in love are also porn is simply ridiculous.
Aha, but it’s “emotional porn”! they cry. It engages your emotions and makes you feel, or want to feel, what the characters are feeling. To which I respond: what is the point of reading a novel which doesn’t engage your emotions? If I’m reading a book and I don’t feel sad when the characters are sad, or frustrated when they’re frustrated, or scared when they’re scared, then I’ll probably put it down and never finish it. We’re supposed to be engaged by a story.
What bothers me even more than the porn comparison is the overall tone of these articles, especially when they’re written by men. “Oh, those poor silly little women,” they seem to be saying. “We can’t let them read things like that, it might fill their silly little heads with ideas and then us men will have to live up to Mr. Darcy instead of being able to sit around watching football and putting off mowing the lawn.” It’s appallingly sexist.
Even the secular articles which don’t try to convince you that romance novels are sinful take this tone. One doctor in England had an article – again, I can’t find the link – where she accused Mills and Boon (our Harlequin) novels of causing unplanned pregnancies. “Women read these books,” she said, “and then think it’s okay to have unprotected sex, and then they get pregnant and the father isn’t anything like a romantic hero, and that’s why we have so many single mothers: Mills and Boon novels.” (I’m paraphrasing from memory, obviously, but that was the gist of her argument.)
Look. If you’re using Harlequin romance novels as your guide to life, you have bigger problems than a possible unplanned pregnancy in your future. But I have yet to meet anyone who goes around asking herself what the heroine of The Greek Tycoon’s Pregnant Virgin Mistress Dilemma would do in every situation. Women read those books for an escape from humdrum every day life, not for realistic plots and characters.
I’m not married, so I can’t say whether reading romance novels makes you less in love with your husband. I do know that a lot of romance novelists get letters like the one Teresa Medeiros often talks about, from a woman who’d had a hysterectomy and was afraid she’d never feel any desire for her husband again, until she read one of Medeiros’s books. I also know that it isn’t romance novels which gave me my ideas of what men should be, it was Lord of the Rings. And that while it’s true that love stories in books and movies make me wish for romance in my own life, so far at least it hasn’t turned me into a romance-crazed ninny. It’s more of a “*wistful sigh* I hope the right guy comes along someday” feeling.
But that’s just me. If reading stories about romance fills you with contempt for your husband, or makes you want to run out and have a baby with the first Italian billionaire or vampire you find, maybe you should be looking elsewhere for your reading material.